Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? – A Reflection on Fame, Family, and Finding One’s Voice
When I first heard about Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? by Crystal Smith Paul, I was immediately intrigued. The promise of a glamorous movie star, complex themes around motherhood and identity, and a storyline woven with racial undertones all tugged at my literary heartstrings. As a devoted reader who relishes stories unafraid to tackle the messiness of human experience, I eagerly dove into this highly anticipated novel.
At its core, the book revolves around the enigmatic Kitty Karr Tate, a late White movie star whose decision to bequeath her vast fortune to the St. John sisters—a trio of wealthy Black women—stirs a pot of questions about privilege, identity, and the heavy weight of expectation. The juxtaposition of Kitty’s life and the St. John sisters’ experiences creates fertile ground for thematic exploration. I truly appreciated the engaging portrayal of Kitty; her complexity felt real and relatable, drawing me in with a compelling air of nostalgia. However, the book’s execution often fell short of its lofty premise.
One of the more profound aspects of the book is its dual timeline structure, alternating between Kitty’s past and the present day of 2017. While I understood the intention behind setting it in this particular era—particularly given the racial dynamics—it left me feeling somewhat disconnected. There were moments that felt like a critique of the soundbites of social justice that pervade contemporary discourse, but the urgency of 2023 could have added an extra layer of relevance.
I found myself grappling with the portrayal of the St. John sisters. Elise, our older sister and main point-of-view character, carries an air of unhappiness that becomes quite monotonous over time. Her emotional journey appears underdeveloped, rendering it difficult to empathize with her struggles. The pacing of the narrative felt laborious, bogged down by a plethora of side characters who, while adding to the richness of the story, often blurred together in a way that dulled their impact. The "A HA!" moments came too late in the game, and the initial allure of Kitty’s legacy fizzled before a satisfying climax could take hold.
What truly stood out was Paul’s ability to write Kitty compellingly, infusing her chapters with a zest that made me yearn for more. Reading about Kitty’s relationships, desires, and fears was a genuine pleasure. The past sections of the book were binge-worthy—filled with intrigue and rich storytelling. Each turn in her life felt significant, almost illuminating the ghosts of Hollywood’s past with a sense of authenticity rarely seen.
Ultimately, Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? is not without its merits. The relevant social commentary urging us to reflect on privilege and disparity is thought-provoking, even if it sometimes veers into convoluted territory. Readers who enjoy a cocktail of celebrity culture, family dynamics, and social issues may find value here, but those seeking a focused narrative might leave feeling unsatisfied.
In conclusion, while I applauded the ambition and themes explored in this novel, the journey was sometimes marred by slow pacing and a lack of character depth. It left me pondering what more could have been achieved had the execution matched the ambition. For fans of Evelyn Hugo and those looking for stories rich with complex layers, this book may still be worth delving into—Kitty Karr Tate’s star power shines brightly, even if some of the surrounding characters struggle to keep pace.
Discover more about Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? on GoodReads >>