Review of Black Woods Blue Sky by Eowyn Ivey: A Beautiful Misstep
When I first stumbled upon Black Woods Blue Sky, the name Eowyn Ivey piqued my interest, especially given her reputation for weaving rich, immersive stories. As a self-proclaimed fan of retellings—particularly the beloved Beauty and the Beast—I was intrigued by the promotional material suggesting a fairy-tale reimagining. Little did I know that what awaited me would be a tangled exploration of themes, characters, and a narrative that diverged from my expectations in ways I couldn’t have anticipated.
At its core, the book is marketed as a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, but this assertion feels fraught with complications. Ivey’s initial inspirations evoked warm nostalgia for her childhood memories of the classic tale, yet as I dived deeper, the threads connecting her narrative to the original began to unravel. While I recognize the author’s intent to interrogate and reframe the narratives we’ve been handed, the execution left me grappling with its authenticity—and its coherence.
The character of Birdie is difficult to empathize with. As a single mother battling her own demons, she often descends into solipsistic behavior that oscillates between reckless and painfully misguided. The dynamics between her and Arthur, a bear and the embodiment of the "animal bridegroom," struggle to find balance, often veering into uncomfortable territory. The narrative grapples with themes of love and control, yet I felt uneasy at many of the encounters between Birdie and Arthur—what was intended as a troubled romance instead traversed the lanes of misunderstandings and mischaracterizations that detracted from the graspable beauty of the original tale.
Ivey’s writing style shimmers with vivid descriptions of Alaska’s wild, enchanting landscape, making the setting a breathtaking backdrop for the story. Her ability to paint a scene is commendable, immersing readers in a world that pulses with life. However, as lovely as the prose may be, it could not compensate for the narrative’s shortcomings. I found myself drawn to the beauty in her descriptions, yet longing for the poignancy of character development that never quite arrived.
The convoluted messaging around accountability and agency within relationships became, for me, the crux of my disappointment. Notably absent was a coherent exploration of the darker themes introduced—ones that Ivey seemingly sought to engage with but ultimately left muddled. The insistence on mixing fairy-tale elements with discussions of domestic violence and neglect reached beyond the surface, yet did not sufficiently connect, leaving many crucial conversations dangling uncontextualized.
And so, we arrive at the ending—the resolve that felt painfully contrived. Reflecting on my reading experience, I can’t help but wonder at the potential that shimmered beneath the surface. Despite its missteps, Black Woods Blue Sky still finds an emergent resonance for those grappling with trauma—though perhaps in ways it did not intend.
This book may not deliver the beloved retelling I hoped for, but its vivid landscapes and hints at deeper themes may yet resonate with readers willing to navigate its complications. If you’re intrigued by the exploration of human emotions amidst myth and natural beauty, this might be a book worth considering. Yet, for those seeking a faithful retelling of Beauty and the Beast, prepare for a mixed bag that may leave you pondering more questions than it answers.
In my own reading journey, I emerged from Black Woods Blue Sky humbled, perhaps a little disillusioned, yet still appreciative of its attempts to tackle the complexities of love and loss—even if it faltered along the way.
Discover more about Black Woods Blue Sky on GoodReads >>
